Never Not the Minister

Post Author: Nancy McDonald Ladd

It can be difficult to receive care when you are called to be a care-giver.

It was scary and stressful, and I’m still not over the shock of realizing he and I might not be invincible after all. It was also the first time that I have been on the receiving end of my congregation’s big-hearted approach to pastoral care. I’m still reeling over how strange and wonderful that felt.

See, I’m the minister–right. I’m the giver of pastoral care, not the receiver. I am the font of comfort and the number one resource in my congregation for compassionate nods-of-the-head and hugs-only-when-appropriate. I am the pastor, and since I never remember my local priest comforting my family very much when I was a kid, I’ve seldom (if ever) really known what it was to be pastored to in a time of trauma, which is why I was confused this week, if honored and grateful at the same time.

When hubby was in surgery, I was sitting on the floor of the only place in the hospital with reception grasping a cell phone in each hand while talking to our parents and family members, giving them updates and generally just trying to hold it together. As I sat on the floor juggling these cell phones and wondering if I even had it in me to cry, one of my more wonderful congregants walked up to me.

Here’s where the story gets surprising. When I saw her, my first thought was not “Oh, how lovely that she’s come to see me,” but rather, “oh crap there’s one of my congregants and I haven’t showered in a couple of days and am not really able to talk to her like a minister right now and I’m sitting on the floor in the pajama shirt I was wearing when we fled the house at three am and she’s probably got some relative in surgery and I didn’t even know about it and I hope she’s ok and, deep breath I need to get off of these two phones and talk to my congregant.”

I thought all of those things in about two seconds flat. It took me a good ten minutes to realize that she was actually there to see me. That’s right. I assumed she had her own traumas or issues to attend to and just happened to be here, in the surgical waiting area for ten solid minutes, for reasons utterly unconnected to my suffering husband. While my husband was in surgery. I found it inconceivable that someone might be there to see me.

Once I figured it out I was touched and so glad that she had come, not just because it turned out to be lovely to have some company in that difficult time, but because it taught me something about myself and the nature of ministry. Reflecting on it, the mental block that kept me from seeing her generous offer of care was strong. There is, apparently, a good bit of my self-identity as a minister connected to my role as care-giver, and I couldn’t move very smoothly from that role to another one.

As leaders, pastors, people of faith–how do we manage to be both caregivers and care receivers? How do we let the good work of the church not only emanate from us but come back to us? People forget at their peril and the peril of their congregants the fact that a minister is never not the minister. It’s when people forget that fact that the really bad stuff happens. Those in ministry do no favors to their churches when they let their professional boundaries and ministerial identity slide away. It’s not a costume you can take off or a role that can be shed like a snake’s skin on Friday night and picked back up on Sunday morning. Even sitting on the floor unshowered and frightened in a pajama shirt with the man I love in the operating room, I’m still the minister.

And yet, there are times when the minister must allow for the possibility of being cared for in appropriate ways by the people she gives her love and labor to. It needs to cross our minds that the good people of our churches may just be there for us when we need them, that even the minister with good professional boundaries and a strong sense of her own calling can stand to be on the receiving end of God’s love as manifested in the love of a church community. That is, after all, what a church community is for.

Hubby’s fine, by the way. My congregation is busily taking good care of others among us who are in need of care. I’m left both surprised by my response to their compassion and infinitely grateful for it.

Image by: Matheus Ferrero
Used with permission
7 replies
  1. Stacey
    Stacey says:

    Great article – I had a similar experience when I was hospitalized last summer, and found myself almost resistant to being cared for by others, especially my congregation! Working out what it means to live in community is always surprising. Thanks!

  2. A.Lin
    A.Lin says:

    As a pastor, I am trained to see hurting people and minister to them. However, I have been hurting myself lately, and letting others into my life so they may minister to me is not an easy task. Whether it be my tendency to rely on self or my desire not to admit my weaknesses, God has been using that sermon to speak to my heart and convict me about the notion that I do not need anyone’s help.
    I think that we all need to be ministered to from time to time. I just need to convince my head that it would be fine for me to be on the receiving end of ministry.

  3. C
    C says:

    Hey, finally a voice from a UU young woman minister! Good to hear it. Thanks for your words. –from a 20something UU woman minister

  4. ann
    ann says:

    Thanks, Nancy. I was just talking yesterday to someone about the difficulty of receiving and not giving care. I’m reminded of Peter protesting when Jesus washed his feet.
    C: If you’d like to see more articles by a UU, submit one! We’re always looking for pieces. Go to “Contact & Submissions” in the above banner to find out more.

  5. M
    M says:

    I truly do appreciate your article. I have great difficulty being cared for by the congregants for two reasons. When I am most vulnerable is when I need to rage against ____(insert offender) because raging is part of the process. However, it is rarely appropriate for the parishoners to experience that with me. Also, I feel that no matter how much I discourage it, I am the God-figure for the congregation. Our society and sometimes our institutions still encourage the pastoral role as the stand-in for God. I think it is a long and difficult hurdle to jump to come to a place where those parishoners can see their pastor as a horribly broken human being. I fear that “caring for me” before that is possible would be quite detrimental to the community. Any thoughts on these?

  6. Heather
    Heather says:

    Our bishop went through prostate cancer a few years ago, and was very open with how his treatments were going, how much he was able to work, the prognosis, and so on. He said later how amazed he was by the experience of being lifted in prayer like that, how he felt himself to be cared for by so many. It also, he said, made it easier for others to approach him about their own cancer experiences, because he’d been there.
    It really opened my eyes to how mutual ministry is supposed to be. We say (don’t we?) that we support the ministry of the laity, that our role is to equip the saints for the work of ministry.
    For the person who got me a juice box when I got dizzy during the service when I was pregnant, for the person who brought me a care package when my gall bladder was removed, it was so obviously a privilege for them to do that. It was like, they know how much I give them and they just relished the opportunity to give something back.

  7. Teri
    Teri says:

    I have been thinking about this a lot, and then this article appeared, and then I kept thinking, and I’m still not sure I have coherent thoughts, but I’m going to try.
    I’m not entirely sure it’s really possible for people to trust us enough to REALLY let us in until they have seen that we are willing to trust them. How can they care for others if we don’t let them care for us? Does that place us “above” them somehow–sort of like “well, you all care for each other, but I can’t let you do that for me”?
    I admit that I’m not good at allowing others to take care of me, no matter who they are (any of my ex-boyfriends out there who want to testify? Go ahead.). But I am becoming more and more convinced that without some (though perhaps limited) vulnerability and even a simple opportunity for the congregation to care for me, I can’t be their pastor. Because then I’m superhuman, able to respond to every need perfectly, always available to care deeply, etc…and that’s just not true. As a human being, I have limitations and needy moments and, especially as a single woman living far away from family and most long-time friends, my congregation has stepped up to care for me at some really important times. I think that is at the heart of our pastoral relationship with one another.
    I don’t know if that made any sense at all, but I tried…


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *